It’s a Sunday in Major League Baseball, so get in early with our Underdog Fantasy Pick’em predictions! We have a full slate across multiple time zones, culminating with one of the game’s biggest – or at least talked about – rivalries with Sunday Night Baseball in the Bronx. We will stay away from the Red Sox – Yankees game, as the OddsShopper pick’em tool found fantastic value elsewhere. It’s a massive plus anytime we can get some help in gaining an edge against the market. Here are the top two MLB plays to build a 3x winner on Underdog!
It’s a simple question at Underdog Fantasy optimizer tool designed to help you build winning entries.
Editor’s Note: Want more of Eytan or the OddsShopper crew and community? Come our community of like-minded people on Discord!
Underdog Fantasy MLB Pick’em Predictions Today
Looking for more guide to Underdog Fantasy. You can get a first-time deposit match up to $250 with code EYTAN.
Jordan Westburg H/L Than 1.5 Total Bases
The entire planet is awaiting the expected regression in this game, following the Oakland A’s 19-8 walloping of the Orioles. While Baltimore can salvage the season series with a win, it doesn’t mean every hitter on the team is going yard. Mitch Spence will go for Oakland, and like the team he represents, it hasn’t been a stellar year for either. Jordan is on the opposite end of that spectrum, clearly having a monster year, especially making good .
He’s currently working a modest five game hit streak, with only one of those games with multiple hits. Surviving may be a little extreme, but even in the past 15 games, Westburg isn’t smashing each at bat. While his stretch of hitting safely in 13 of those 15 is impressive, he has just three games with multiple hits. A single or a rare miss on each at bat is absolutely possible here, and worth the price we get thanks to OddsShopper.
The implied odds at Underdog for Lower than 1.5 Total Bases is -122. That beats the -135 true odds established via our pick’em tool, giving us a 4.5% edge. That is playable every single time.
Underdog Fantasy Pick’em Prediction: Jordan Westburg Lower than 1.5 Total Bases
Manny Machado H/L Than 1.5 Total Bases
The Diamondbacks are spent yet they keep finding ways to win. Their bullpen is taxed as no starting pitcher on this road trip seems interested in pitching deeper into games. All setting up a massive offensive explosion for the San Diego Padres. Right?
That’s certainly possible against Ryne Nelson but we still see significant value in fading one Padres player, specifically Manny Machado. He’s been hitting the ball in bunches but will leave some at bats out there for the taking.
Nelson isn’t the best candidate to shut down Machado but it doesn’t need to be that result in order to keep the latter off the basepath. Machado has a 21% K rate which is higher than any other every day player.

Once again we find edge thanks to the pick’em tool. The -122 implied odds are simply better than the -126 true odds giving us a 1.5% edge against the market.
Underdog Fantasy Pick’em Prediction: Manny Machado Lower Than 1.5 Total Bases
OddsShopper’s MLB Tools & Tips
Looking for more 2023-24 MLB predictions or random data? MLB Weather Report page if you’re starting to itch for the summer months!